When Healthcare Depends on Someone Fighting for You

Laura Sanger's story raises a difficult question: what happens to people with severe learning disabilities when their pain goes unheard?

In a report published by STV News, Kate Sanger describes her struggle to get medical attention for her 34-year-old daughter, Laura, who has a rare genetic condition and requires round-the-clock care.

Laura has been experiencing severe back pain, leaving her spending much of her time in bed. An annual health check identified a problem, but six months later, she is still waiting for an MRI scan.

NHS Tayside explained that MRI scans requiring general anaesthesia can take longer because specialist support is needed. That is an important practical consideration. But Laura's experience raises a broader question about how healthcare systems respond to people with complex needs.

What happens when someone cannot clearly communicate their symptoms or has no family member able to advocate for them?

The inequality is measurable

This is not simply a concern raised by individual families.

A 2025 peer-reviewed study published in BMJ Open, using linked Scottish census and mortality records, found that adults aged 25–34 with learning disabilities were approximately nine times more likely to die from treatable conditions than people of the same age without learning disabilities.

A separate 2026 study in PLOS Medicine, examining mortality records in England, found that nearly two in five deaths among adults with severe or profound learning disabilities were classified as avoidable. Around two-thirds of these avoidable deaths involved conditions considered treatable.

These findings do not establish what caused the delay in Laura's case. They do, however, reveal a wider pattern of unequal health outcomes that requires serious attention.

When pain is difficult to communicate

Recognising illness can be more complicated when someone cannot describe their symptoms in conventional ways.

Pain may be expressed through changes in behaviour, movement, sleep or distress. Healthcare professionals need to recognise these signals rather than assume they are simply part of someone's disability.

This is particularly important because of diagnostic overshadowing: when symptoms of a separate medical condition are mistakenly attributed to a person's existing disability.

The Royal College of Nursing's guidance on pain assessment highlights the importance of appropriate assessment tools and listening to people who know the patient well.

Family carers can provide valuable information, but their involvement should strengthen healthcare assessment, not replace it.

From identifying problems to treating them

Scotland introduced annual health checks for people with learning disabilities in 2022. Progress has been made, but implementation remains incomplete.

According to an analysis of Scottish Government statistics by the Fraser of Allander Institute, only 35% of identified eligible adults were offered a health check in 2025/26, although this represents a substantial improvement on previous years.

Laura's experience also shows why health checks are only one part of the solution.

Identifying a problem is important. Ensuring that it leads to timely investigation and treatment is equally important.

Policy evaluation should therefore look beyond the number of health checks completed. It should also examine waiting times, access to diagnostic services, reasonable adjustments and whether patients ultimately receive the treatment they need.

The invisible work of advocacy

There is another dimension that deserves attention.

Family carers are often the people who notice changes, document symptoms, contact professionals and follow up when appointments or investigations are delayed.

This work takes time, creates emotional pressure and can become another responsibility added to already demanding caring roles.

But there is also a more fundamental concern.

If access to appropriate healthcare depends on having a persistent and informed family advocate, what happens to people who do not have one?

That question connects disability rights, healthcare inequality and the hidden responsibilities of unpaid carers.

At the Disability Carer Initiative, we believe these are questions that deserve systematic research and careful policy evaluation.

Because a healthcare system should not depend on who can fight hardest to be heard.